Forum: empire-en
Board: [590] Ideas, Suggestions & Feedback
Topic: [364935] Military Academy - is it worth having?
[-364935]
Venom (ASIA1) [ASIA1]
:: June 11, 2019, 12:45 p.m.
So for 460 tablets, I can get my vet crossbowmen/vet macemen an extra 7.64 combat strength. Which I think is bonkers.
I am attacking with baseline 185% strength. I lose 20-30 troops every attack.
So at 77 tablets an attack 460/77=6 (common for the average player).
I require to lose:
6*20=120
6*20=180
So realistically you lose 150 troops + tools for an extra 4.1% overall strength (7.64 divide 185).
My question is: will this building actually provide a profit?
An average player loses 80-120 troops in an FC attack that doesn't use tools, or less than 80 without tools. So for every 25 troops lost - you make one back with the additional 4.1%
So 2 hours of attacking for a good player, is about 30 attacks.
30 attacks multiplied by an average of 80 losses per hit is 2,400.
2400/25= 96 troops.
So to answer the title question of, "is it worth having?" the answer is no.
Sorry for the scuffed writing, very tired and stressed out.
I am attacking with baseline 185% strength. I lose 20-30 troops every attack.
So at 77 tablets an attack 460/77=6 (common for the average player).
I require to lose:
6*20=120
6*20=180
So realistically you lose 150 troops + tools for an extra 4.1% overall strength (7.64 divide 185).
My question is: will this building actually provide a profit?
An average player loses 80-120 troops in an FC attack that doesn't use tools, or less than 80 without tools. So for every 25 troops lost - you make one back with the additional 4.1%
So 2 hours of attacking for a good player, is about 30 attacks.
30 attacks multiplied by an average of 80 losses per hit is 2,400.
2400/25= 96 troops.
So to answer the title question of, "is it worth having?" the answer is no.
Sorry for the scuffed writing, very tired and stressed out.
[5056664]
Kage (ASIA1) [ASIA1]
:: June 11, 2019, 1:27 p.m.
This building is nothing more but just a waste of space, po.
Like glory memorial and willow of experience.
The academy does not provide or replace the po after you took a deco down, so thats -300 po and around 100 food.
Not much, but lemme tell you what is also not much.
Losing troops, who cares if we lose 2 or 5 troops less in a attack during nomads, samurais?
Lemme tell you, nobody. Cuz when you start attacking those events, you don't care about your troops, nor the loses.
Most of the people (like me), actually want to lose troops, during fc/bc, nom/sams.
So this building is nothing more but just another way of making the people use their last few coins, rubyes, sam/nom tokens to activate some crap bonuses which will not have that much impact in your battle reports in the end.
Also, who in the world came up with the bonuses for that type of troops, not all of us have the reseach tower maxed to the new units.
I understand that by upgrading it you unlock new tier of troops, but come on..
Even the relic wood build thingy is more worth to have it lmao
Like glory memorial and willow of experience.
The academy does not provide or replace the po after you took a deco down, so thats -300 po and around 100 food.
Not much, but lemme tell you what is also not much.
Losing troops, who cares if we lose 2 or 5 troops less in a attack during nomads, samurais?
Lemme tell you, nobody. Cuz when you start attacking those events, you don't care about your troops, nor the loses.
Most of the people (like me), actually want to lose troops, during fc/bc, nom/sams.
So this building is nothing more but just another way of making the people use their last few coins, rubyes, sam/nom tokens to activate some crap bonuses which will not have that much impact in your battle reports in the end.
Also, who in the world came up with the bonuses for that type of troops, not all of us have the reseach tower maxed to the new units.
I understand that by upgrading it you unlock new tier of troops, but come on..
Even the relic wood build thingy is more worth to have it lmao
[5056681]
Philt123 (GB1) [GB1]
:: June 11, 2019, 2:02 p.m.
In a nutshell nope, summed up pretty well above. I wont be building one any time soon even if I am swimming in construction tokens.
[5057689]
Player X (GB1) [GB1]
:: June 16, 2019, 7:25 p.m.
It really is incredibly expensive and its effects are impractical and ridiculous- 2 hours worth of a tiny benefit for a mediocre soldier for 80,000 coins? As I said, ridiculous.
[5105639]
UserJAMS (US1) [US1]
:: March 13, 2020, 6:11 a.m.
I thought the effects piled on and lasted forever?
[5106198]
EdMohrmann (US1) [US1]
:: March 17, 2020, 3:57 a.m.
DA, pure and simple...